Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

Ok this is the spiel (I assume the back cover) for Smith’s book:

Richard, Rick, Ricky - more like a Rocky story which led to a rollercoaster of fabulous nights, taking a down-to-earth lad from Hyde to Vegas and into the Boxing Hall of Fame. With those spine-tingling Blue Moon ring walks, and rip-roaring action, Richard Hatton MBE was both a sporting icon and a working-class hero.'

As 'The Voice of Boxing' delivered Ricky Hatton's eulogy, Adam Smith's opening words echoed through Manchester Cathedral and across the country. Ricky Hatton's death stunned the world in a way few sporting losses ever have. Tribute after tribute poured in, from the lads on the estates to the A-listers on the red carpets. Everybody loved Ricky. Everybody felt they had lost someone who belonged to them. Ricky Hatton was their voice, their joy, their fighter.

Written with the support of Ricky's friends and family, Adam Smith tells his extraordinary story in full. From Ricky's early career highlights and his iconic Blue Moon ring walks to his title bouts and fight nights in Las Vegas, as well as his struggles after retirement, his life is captured in vivid detail. Adam was one of Ricky's closest friends and was with him from the very beginning - at ringside, backstage, in bars, cars, takeaways and late-night hotel corridors, through all the triumphs, meltdowns, laughter, heartbreak and healing. He writes movingly about how it was Ricky who helped him through his own battle with cancer, providing him with the strength and support he needed to recover. Adam didn't just tell Ricky's story on television, he lived it with him. His laugh. His energy. His compassion. His heart.

All of it lives on in these pages
.

Was Adam Smith really one of Ricky’s best friends? This preface or whatever suggests Smith was Hatton’s best mate from schoolboy days…. That he was like a brother to him… Does it mention Smith sacked Hatton from Sky after using him as his best man at his wedding 2 weeks previously? This text must be written by Smith himself, and predictably, even though it’s meant to be a book about Ricky, the book summary is about Smith himself… as predicted…. He really couldn’t wait to make a book about Hatton and himself, published barely a year after the Hitman’s passing. So he must’ve started working on it soon after. And I see the book has the family’s blessing… I can see smith harassing the Hatton family for his book whilst they’re still grieving. What a low life.
coneye
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 8694
Joined: 21 Jun 2004, 06:00

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by coneye »

Who gave there blessing ,, his kids and brother , or his Mam and Dad
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

coneye wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 14:05 Who gave there blessing ,, his kids and brother , or his Mam and Dad
I would guess mum and dad. Probably wanted a cut of profit too.

Smith also boasts that he will look after Campbell and Hatton’s other kids for life. Yeah right.
keithmoonhangover
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17257
Joined: 16 Sep 2010, 10:42

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by keithmoonhangover »

You don't have to like Adam Smith's commentary, you just need to learn to love it.
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

keithmoonhangover wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 14:14 You don't have to like Adam Smith's commentary, you just need to learn to love it.
Thank you Confucius. Although TBH the main reason I’m gonna watch the Katie Taylor fight is purely to see how awful Smith’s commentary is :lol: :lol:
keithmoonhangover
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 17257
Joined: 16 Sep 2010, 10:42

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by keithmoonhangover »

JamesPhilips wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 14:26
keithmoonhangover wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 14:14 You don't have to like Adam Smith's commentary, you just need to learn to love it.
Thank you Confucius. Although TBH the main reason I’m gonna watch the Katie Taylor fight is purely to see how awful Smith’s commentary is :lol: :lol:
Haha. I learned that phrase from a guy I know who used to be a bouncer. He was a military police officer, a mountain of a man and once he subdued the drunk, he'd walk them out and say, "You don't have to like it, you just need to learn to love it."
forcefraser
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5550
Joined: 17 Jun 2008, 06:15

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by forcefraser »

I'm on the lash and not watching the Taylor event

How is Smith's form? Dramatic growl and over indulgent waffle or a bearable start with clear signs of degeneration to come?
Grilling Machine
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3207
Joined: 16 Sep 2005, 02:28

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Grilling Machine »

forcefraser wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 15:10How is Smith's form? Dramatic growl and over indulgent waffle or a bearable start with clear signs of degeneration to come?
Classic friendly torturer!
Glass Joe
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 5058
Joined: 08 Feb 2012, 10:29

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Glass Joe »

Gets even worse smith going to Vegas for benn fight
Ruthless-RKO
Welterweight
Posts: 104290
Joined: 24 Apr 2016, 11:59

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Ruthless-RKO »

Glass Joe wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:51 Gets even worse smith going to Vegas for benn fight
Because it’s the Ring card, there’s a chance he MAY NOT be there.

Might be Mike Copp and a few Americans
mickey1975
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 23212
Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by mickey1975 »

Ruthless-RKO wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:52
Glass Joe wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:51 Gets even worse smith going to Vegas for benn fight
Because it’s the Ring card, there’s a chance he MAY NOT be there.

Might be Mike Copp and a few Americans
He said he's going.
Ruthless-RKO
Welterweight
Posts: 104290
Joined: 24 Apr 2016, 11:59

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Ruthless-RKO »

mickey1975 wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:57
Ruthless-RKO wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:52
Glass Joe wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:51 Gets even worse smith going to Vegas for benn fight
Because it’s the Ring card, there’s a chance he MAY NOT be there.

Might be Mike Copp and a few Americans
He said he's going.
FFS.

I’m gonna watch paramount+ stream then.
Rezzer1967
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 190
Joined: 20 Feb 2009, 14:09

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Rezzer1967 »

Ruthless-RKO wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 18:01
mickey1975 wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:57
Ruthless-RKO wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 17:52

Because it’s the Ring card, there’s a chance he MAY NOT be there.

Might be Mike Copp and a few Americans
He said he's going.
FFS.




I’m gonna watch paramount+ stream then.
He’s won’t give anyone an opportunity to do some commentary. He’d kick his nan down the stairs to have the chance to commentate on a Jimmy Sains fight. An before anyone says, yes I know he’s had cancer and yes I’m delighted he’s recovered and yes, I still think he’s the worse commentator in sporting history and that’s saying something.
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

You can be sure that Smith will reference the Taylor Croke park fight again and again in his future commentary
overhand_right
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1114
Joined: 19 Jul 2003, 07:25

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by overhand_right »

JamesPhilips wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 13:49 Ok this is the spiel (I assume the back cover) for Smith’s book:

Richard, Rick, Ricky - more like a Rocky story which led to a rollercoaster of fabulous nights, taking a down-to-earth lad from Hyde to Vegas and into the Boxing Hall of Fame. With those spine-tingling Blue Moon ring walks, and rip-roaring action, Richard Hatton MBE was both a sporting icon and a working-class hero.'

As 'The Voice of Boxing' delivered Ricky Hatton's eulogy, Adam Smith's opening words echoed through Manchester Cathedral and across the country. Ricky Hatton's death stunned the world in a way few sporting losses ever have. Tribute after tribute poured in, from the lads on the estates to the A-listers on the red carpets. Everybody loved Ricky. Everybody felt they had lost someone who belonged to them. Ricky Hatton was their voice, their joy, their fighter.

Written with the support of Ricky's friends and family, Adam Smith tells his extraordinary story in full. From Ricky's early career highlights and his iconic Blue Moon ring walks to his title bouts and fight nights in Las Vegas, as well as his struggles after retirement, his life is captured in vivid detail. Adam was one of Ricky's closest friends and was with him from the very beginning - at ringside, backstage, in bars, cars, takeaways and late-night hotel corridors, through all the triumphs, meltdowns, laughter, heartbreak and healing. He writes movingly about how it was Ricky who helped him through his own battle with cancer, providing him with the strength and support he needed to recover. Adam didn't just tell Ricky's story on television, he lived it with him. His laugh. His energy. His compassion. His heart.

All of it lives on in these pages
.

Was Adam Smith really one of Ricky’s best friends? This preface or whatever suggests Smith was Hatton’s best mate from schoolboy days…. That he was like a brother to him… Does it mention Smith sacked Hatton from Sky after using him as his best man at his wedding 2 weeks previously? This text must be written by Smith himself, and predictably, even though it’s meant to be a book about Ricky, the book summary is about Smith himself… as predicted…. He really couldn’t wait to make a book about Hatton and himself, published barely a year after the Hitman’s passing. So he must’ve started working on it soon after. And I see the book has the family’s blessing… I can see smith harassing the Hatton family for his book whilst they’re still grieving. What a low life.
Smith's narcissism aside, that is some dreadful writing.
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

overhand_right wrote: 07 Sep 2026, 15:25
JamesPhilips wrote: 05 Sep 2026, 13:49 Ok this is the spiel (I assume the back cover) for Smith’s book:

Richard, Rick, Ricky - more like a Rocky story which led to a rollercoaster of fabulous nights, taking a down-to-earth lad from Hyde to Vegas and into the Boxing Hall of Fame. With those spine-tingling Blue Moon ring walks, and rip-roaring action, Richard Hatton MBE was both a sporting icon and a working-class hero.'

As 'The Voice of Boxing' delivered Ricky Hatton's eulogy, Adam Smith's opening words echoed through Manchester Cathedral and across the country. Ricky Hatton's death stunned the world in a way few sporting losses ever have. Tribute after tribute poured in, from the lads on the estates to the A-listers on the red carpets. Everybody loved Ricky. Everybody felt they had lost someone who belonged to them. Ricky Hatton was their voice, their joy, their fighter.

Written with the support of Ricky's friends and family, Adam Smith tells his extraordinary story in full. From Ricky's early career highlights and his iconic Blue Moon ring walks to his title bouts and fight nights in Las Vegas, as well as his struggles after retirement, his life is captured in vivid detail. Adam was one of Ricky's closest friends and was with him from the very beginning - at ringside, backstage, in bars, cars, takeaways and late-night hotel corridors, through all the triumphs, meltdowns, laughter, heartbreak and healing. He writes movingly about how it was Ricky who helped him through his own battle with cancer, providing him with the strength and support he needed to recover. Adam didn't just tell Ricky's story on television, he lived it with him. His laugh. His energy. His compassion. His heart.

All of it lives on in these pages
.

Was Adam Smith really one of Ricky’s best friends? This preface or whatever suggests Smith was Hatton’s best mate from schoolboy days…. That he was like a brother to him… Does it mention Smith sacked Hatton from Sky after using him as his best man at his wedding 2 weeks previously? This text must be written by Smith himself, and predictably, even though it’s meant to be a book about Ricky, the book summary is about Smith himself… as predicted…. He really couldn’t wait to make a book about Hatton and himself, published barely a year after the Hitman’s passing. So he must’ve started working on it soon after. And I see the book has the family’s blessing… I can see smith harassing the Hatton family for his book whilst they’re still grieving. What a low life.
Smith's narcissism aside, that is some dreadful writing.
Agreed. There’s also something very distasteful about it…..
Grilling Machine
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3207
Joined: 16 Sep 2005, 02:28

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by Grilling Machine »

I've reached the point of not watching fights I'm moderately interested in if he's commentating, and when he's unavoidable I mute.

In this internet age we're long overdue the option to disable commentary for all sports, enjoying solely the venue mics via the sound director.
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

This is a very interesting article about Hatton’s inheritance, the alleged ‘charity’ The Ricky Hatton Foundation, Adam Smith, Paul Speak, Smith’s book, the involvement of a convicted fraudster…. Questions about the Smith / Sky situation and lots of other shenanigans. Might’ve be worth a new post really


https://craigscott209.substack.com/p/cf ... medium=web
JamesPhilips
Super Bantamweight
Posts: 6779
Joined: 19 Mar 2021, 06:43

Re: Can anything be done about Adam Smith on commentary?

Post by JamesPhilips »

Ricky Hatton Foundation

It’s a real shame I need to start this week’s (Contaminated) Food for Thought with this subject matter, but I suppose somebody has to do it. I should say this section is posing questions - rather than accusations. But some answers would appease many.

Serious questions are being asked of the Ricky Hatton Foundation, the ‘charity’ (not registered as a charity as yet and currently a Limited Company as per Companies House) set up with the mission statement claiming it will:

“continue his work to speak out for and support those with mental health challenges… Trustees are determined to turn sadness into positive action, using the foundation to support meaningful projects… helping to ensure no one has to fight this battle alone.”

That is, of course, admirable. And the purpose of the Foundation appears in alignment with Hatton’s own struggles. But it’s been brought to my attention, by some of those close to the former champion, that they’re unsure how money raised is actually being spent and have raised concerns. They’ve seen nothing disclosed, no posts detailing donations, or financial support for the “projects” or “initiatives” they claim to be determined to support.

Also, the Ricky Hatton Foundation are on record as stating Ringwalk Media 12 – a bespoke boxing content and media management company, in their own words – are managing the social media strategy and comms. It’s extremely bespoke, as it goes, with a locked/protected Twitter account and a whopping 12 followers. Maybe a little too bespoke, one could argue.

The issue with Ringwalk Media 12 isn’t their follower count – who fornicating cares about that. It’s that they are headed by Johnny Pollard, a convicted fraudster.

Pollard was given a suspended jail sentence for eight counts of fraud (initially 22 counts, however the remaining 1 were dropped due to complainants moving overseas or refusing to assist the prosecution). He took over £30,000 from excited would-be holiday lovers, offering non-existent exotic trips.

Pollard “deployed a tactic of false promises” and would “make up lie-after-lie to distract his clients.” Not my words or my opinion, but the words of this article, where Pollard was told by the judge, Mr Ciaran Rankin, that he was “nothing more than a conman.”

Not exactly the social media or communications partner I’d expect a mental health charity (or Foundation) to have at its helm – but maybe I’m being over dramatic? Maybe it’s me. Oh, no, it’s not just me.

Hatton’s former fiancée, and mother of two daughters, Jennifer Dooley was initially a part of the Foundation – but very quickly resigned and stepped away from it. Dooley – who remained supportive of Hatton despite their relationship ending amidst some of his personal difficulties – doesn’t have any link to it. A little strange, no?

DAZN and former Sky head honcho, Adam Smith is closely linked to the Foundation. Smith recently published a book on Hatton, titled ‘The Light That Never Goes Out’ and has been signing copies of it up-and-down the country. Here’s a review on Amazon from a Mr John Howarth:

“Not sure about being a powerful book. It is more about Adam Smith than Ricky Hatton.”

Now, we don’t know how qualified Mr Howarth is to provide his critical assessment of Smith’s writing, so we’ll let that slide. But why are a number of prominent people left out when remembering Hatton and his impact on the sport?

Where the fornicate is Billy Graham? The trainer who worked so closely with Hatton, building and shaping him into the world beater, the people’s champion? I’ve been informed Graham refused. Where is Jane Couch, a long-time friend and former employee of Hatton during his tenure as a promoter? Couch demanded Smith left her out, she and Graham weren’t alone.

How much of that book’s profit is being donated to the Ricky Hatton Foundation? Is it a percentage? Is it a monetary amount per sale? Without stating there’s any wrong doing here, which of course, I can’t be sure of and would hate to think of, it would be remiss to ignore the lack of clarity or commitment. And so, in the interest of fairness, I reached out to the Ricky Hatton Foundation with the following questions:

Who explicitly approved Ricky Hatton’s book?
From the sales of the book, what % was transferred to the Foundation’s account?
As above, what % or monetary figure was given to Adam Smith and Paul Speak from sales of the book or for services agreed?
Can you state, clearly, what charitable activity, donation or monetary figure the Foundation have distributed to further their aims in supporting mental health? (As I can’t find anything at all)
Why did Jennifer Dooley resign very shortly after the creation of the Ricky Hatton Foundation? Did she have any concerns?
I sent those yesterday afternoon and haven’t had a response at time of writing.

I was sent a poster for an event that was published on Facebook earlier today which is too cringe-inducing to even feature on here. But it was for an event being advertised on Sunday 4th October. If I asked Alexa for a completely tone-deaf event title to commemorate a man who’d suffered publicly with alcohol and drug addiction, it couldn’t have bettered this one.

“Buy Ricky a birthday pint!”

Breathtaking, truly.

What’s even more remarkable about this little shindig is that it’s raising money “in aid of” two causes. One is the Ricky Hatton Foundation. The other is listed on the poster as ‘Ricky’s Mates Local Charity Fund.’ What the fornicate is going on here? How do we split the proceeds, guys? How do we know what money goes where? Who is Ricky’s mate and what is his charity fund?

A question was posted under the post asking for any registered charity numbers – it remains unanswered.

*The pub have since cancelled the event and confirmed their funds raised for the local charity have been distributed amongst causes in the area. Tony, the owner, reached out to confirm this and I have no reason to believe they’ve benefitted from any speculative fundraising linked to the Foundation.

This event is most probably disconnected from any work the Ricky Hatton Foundation is officially undertaking or signing off. But it furthers fears that, sadly, Hatton’s name and legacy, his importance to the people of Manchester and of boxing, can be used for some to cash in. ‘Ricky’s Mates Local Charity Fund’ may be genuine and could just be a poorly advertised spot on a poster…

I spoke to a writer who had pledged proceeds of his next book to the Foundation in good faith, someone similarly inquisitive and unsure of how they’re using these donations. I’ve spoken to others close to Hatton who share the same confusion. Donations upwards of £10,000 at a time all sitting in a Limited Company account with Paul Speak (Hatton’s manager), Adam Smith (chief book signer), Campbell Hatton (Hatton’s surviving son) and Jon Eade (some fella) listed as key individuals.

I was given a number for Adam Smith which I messaged respectfully, asking for some time to clarify some of the points raised above. No response. That’s fine. He doesn’t owe me anything and I’m certain he’ll be able to confirm his part in it all. But he explicitly stated in messages that I’ve seen that he: had doubts or concerns about the Foundation himself and that he was told categorically that “nobody was getting paid” from a live event.

Anyway, if you fancy attending a Ricky Hatton Foundation event, there’s one on November 29th at Leeds Irish Centre, a venue that holds up to 800 people (as per online reports). They’re charging £20 per ticket, top line takings of £16,000 if it sells out to that number. And you’ll never guess who the ‘guest speakers’ are? Adam Smith and Paul Speak. Keep it all in house, eh?

Are you being paid for that event, gentlemen? Or doing that for the good of the Foundation?

Anyway, hopefully the Ricky Hatton Foundation can provide examples of their fantastic work – financially or through some tangible initiatives – and I have nothing to suggest any official wrongdoing. It’s purely an ask for transparency. You’d expect that from any other charity or fundraising committee, wouldn’t you? I look forward to hearing from them at their earliest convenience.

We can only hope and remain optimistic that some of the prominent figures in Hatton’s life are acting with integrity. It’s the least he deserves
Post Reply