It's a tough life being an Ali apologist isn't it, IFeel.I Feel Fine wrote:I agree with what you're saying, btw, boxbuzz. Ali wasn't fundamentally perfect, but he had abilities that allowed him to get away with it. When those abilities declined, Ali declined, which is why he had close decisions with Young and Norton that he probably should have lost. But it wasn't because they were fundamentally better. I thought he lost to Shavers too, I'm not sure that Shavers would be called technically brilliant. Ali lost, or should have lost, because he wasn't the same fighter. He was older, he was starting to look older, he was getting slower, he had a lot of wear and tear, especially from Manila. You made the point that if Ali ever encountered someone as good as him who was also fundamentally good, then he might lose. I think that's a good point, and is probably true. But granberry seems to think that just anybody could have beaten Ali if they were any good... which is probably why he has to ignore those "fake" wins over Liston, Patterson and Frazier...BoxBuzz wrote:Ok granmaberry......PLEASE speak to my points regarding natural talent vs the fundamentals and how gifted athletes can sometimes thrive on less knowledge and commitment to the basics and carve out just a wee bit of a career. Even if they do annoy the hell out of you. Now Dont go crazy and make a mockery of this point. I'm not talkin about someone who does not have lick of training, rather those who don't follow the rules quite as well as others and yet have at least limited or perhaps even more success. Naz for example...weak fundamentals but hung in there even with Barrera though he lost.
I mean there is a balance, the absolute best fundamentals don't always rise to the top if they are not equaly gifted with intelligence, good eyesight, instinct and speed. All things you never speak to. Or if you do you add them all up and seem to indicate that they don't mean squat. (That hammer thing I was talkin' about)
Let's get some credibility going here, your more than a name caller, your more than a one trick pony, your more than some old cranky codger who likes to fling poo at ol' boxbuzz. Your an Icon! Your a teacher! Your your....well your granberry for god's sake.
I'm looking for something that tells me "I'm still granberry! And I don't have Alzheimers!"
Was Ali technically perfect? No. But talking about how a 34 year old 20 pounds overweight Ali was exposed, in a relatively close fight that he got a decision in and that some would argue (not me) that he did win... I mean, no one believes that Young would beat the Ali of 72-75, do they? Maybe granberry, but does anyone believe Young beats even a younger 70's Ali, let alone a 60's Ali? I don't see any way. And Doug Jones... uhh... that was not a robbery, and Clay admitted himself that he only trained for a four round fight, and it looked that way as he was gassed late... those fights were close, but not necessarily because Jones and Young had "straighter" right hands...![]()
But I found it funny that he would accept excuses for Louis that he wouldn't accept for Ali. I don't believe Louis-Charles was a definitive fight, or that Charles would beat a younger Louis, but how much less definitive was that fight than Ali-Young, really? Not much in my opinion. I don't like to be judgmental, but granberry acts a lot like a troll.
I definitely feel for you.
Your whining about how old and out of shape Ali was whenever he got his ass kicked
makes me wonder why you don't have the same concerns for his opponents.
What kind of condition was Archie Moore in when he "fought" Ali?
Was Archie young and spry?
What kind of condition was Cleveland Williams in when he fought Ali?
Was he sewed up real good after they took out one kidney and ten feet of his small intestine?
Do you whine and cry for Cleveland Williams and his "condition" like you do for Ali?
Do you whine and cry for Floyd Patterson whose bad back wouldn't even let him stand up straight when he "fought" Ali
in their title fight where Ali showed he had no punching power at all in his very next fight after his supposed one round knockout of Liston?
What "condition" was novice Leon Spinks in when he left for the ring in his second farce with Ali?
Was he filled up with so much cocaine that he left for the ring without his protector on?
Did cornerman Georgie Benton walk out of the ring and the arena after 7 rounds because he was so impressed with Spinks' excellent condition?
You Ali salesman are not consistent in your professed concern about the "condition" of the fighters in the fights Ali had.
Why is that so?
Are you selling something
with your selectiveness ?
LOL