Please give what you think is the #1 boxer ever points in the most important categorys!!!

[Chepppaaa]

from 1-10, 1 being totaly bad, 5 being okay and 10 perfect.

i start first...

for me the best ever is jones jr, in his prime

power 8,5
speed 10
ring IQ 9,5
reflexes 10
chin 7
condition 9
footwork 9,5
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 73,5 out of 80

please copy and paste and try it with your favourite #1 ever boxer.

power
speed
ring IQ
reflexes
chin
condition
footwork
athleticsm

[CrazyHorse]

Ali

power 6.5
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10

[KBB]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

[jamesmcdonnell]

Quality of opposition
Skills
Longevity
Notable wins.

[CrazyHorse]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

Floyd in his prime was unreal. Even at his advanced age he is doing well for himself, top p4p fighter at 38. You look at the past legends and by 38 most of them were already done. Floyd wont be fully appreciated until 5 to 10 years after he retires...maybe longer but one day he will be appreciated more.

[man]

Floyd in his prime was unreal. Even at his advanced age he is doing well for himself, top p4p fighter at 38. You look at the past legends and by 38 most of them were already done. Floyd wont be fully appreciated until 5 to 10 years after he retires...maybe longer but one day he will be appreciated more.

i share that. especially the factor he changed
his game slightly, but just enough to support
his abilities at this age.

i think he will over the years get more credit
for his offensive game. it is just not true that
he is great defensively only.

[CrazyHorse]

it also annoys me when mma fans or even some boxing fans claim floyd is a feather fisted pillow puncher when he is not that bad in terms of power. floyd just doesnt sit down on his punches because he likes to box , move, pivot ect.

[johnswan1]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

[CrazyHorse]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

u know floyd fought with an injured shoulder right? i think the decision should have went to castillo myself but dont think that fight should take away from floyds greatness. heck ali arguably lost to doug jones early in his career, thought jones shoulda got the fight myself

[jamesmcdonnell]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

u know floyd fought with an injured shoulder right? i think the decision should have went to castillo myself but dont think that fight should take away from floyds greatness. heck ali arguably lost to doug jones early in his career, thought jones shoulda got the fight myself

Ali also should have had 2 losses to Kenny Norton. No great shame there, Norton was a great fighter, was unlucky to not get those decisions, and to be around when he was, had he peaked in the 1980's he would have been a world champ, he was just that bit past it when he fought Holmes, but gave him one hell of a fight still!

[Rexob]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

u know floyd fought with an injured shoulder right? i think the decision should have went to castillo myself but dont think that fight should take away from floyds greatness. heck ali arguably lost to doug jones early in his career, thought jones shoulda got the fight myself

Ali also should have had 2 losses to Kenny Norton. No great shame there, Norton was a great fighter, was unlucky to not get those decisions, and to be around when he was, had he peaked in the 1980's he would have been a world champ, he was just that bit past it when he fought Holmes, but gave him one hell of a fight still!

exactly

[squiggy]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

u know floyd fought with an injured shoulder right? i think the decision should have went to castillo myself but dont think that fight should take away from floyds greatness. heck ali arguably lost to doug jones early in his career, thought jones shoulda got the fight myself

I think that's exactly the right way to look at it. Yes, Floyd got a gift against Castillo, but the only reason it's ever worth bringing that up is that so many of his fans -- not to mention Floyd himself -- do so much bragging about his unbeaten record. But that asterisk on his "0" is not the same as disputing what a great fighter he has been.

[CrazyHorse]

Ali was completely shot, not a bit past it! when Holmes kept him up for most of the fight and looked terrible in the process and a shell of his former self at only 38

I think he is referring to Norton vs Holmes

[Tanzio]

SRR = 80

[Rexob]

Ali was completely shot, not a bit past it! when Holmes kept him up for most of the fight and looked terrible in the process and a shell of his former self at only 38

I think he is referring to Norton vs Holmes

[Counter-puncher]

Floyd, power 9.

[keithmoonhangover]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

9 for power? Please explain.

[CrazyHorse]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

9 for power? Please explain.

You never watched Floyd much in his prime have you? Maybe not a 9 but he was a great puncher

[IKSRTFO]

Floyd in his prime won a very controversial decision against Jose Castillo in their first fight. Nobody would have complained at the time had that decision gone to the Mexican.

I do agree that Floyd carries more power and is a lot stronger than he's given credit for. If he really was the feather fisted weaking some make him out to be he would have been found out long before now.

u know floyd fought with an injured shoulder right? i think the decision should have went to castillo myself but dont think that fight should take away from floyds greatness. heck ali arguably lost to doug jones early in his career, thought jones shoulda got the fight myself

Can't use the injury excuse because if you do it for Mayweather Castillo, you have to do it for Mayweather Pacquiao also to be fair.

[keithmoonhangover]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

9 for power? Please explain.

You never watched Floyd much in his prime have you? Maybe not a 9 but he was a great puncher

I've been watching boxing for 38 years, so yes, I've seen Floyd in his prime and I saw enough to know that he is nowhere near a 9 out of 10 power puncher.

[IKSRTFO]

SRR
power 10
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10

Henry Armstrong
power 10
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10

SRL
power 10
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10


And you got people talking about Floyd

[KBB]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

9 for power? Please explain.

You never watched Floyd much in his prime have you? Maybe not a 9 but he was a great puncher

Why do you have a problem with MY rating? Yes I have watched Floyd and in his biggest fights he's stopped his toughest competition in his prime, Manfredy stopped, Corrales stopped and knocked down for the first time in any of his bouts, he hit the deck 5 times but you can just kiss my ass if you don't agree or accept this because this is my rating, not yours.

For all I care you can put him as a 2, 1 or zero and that's your rating, you won't hear nothing from me on it. You guys always have a problem with anyone giving Floyd credit for anything.

[CrazyHorse]

Why do you have a problem with MY rating? Yes I have watched Floyd and in his biggest fights he's stopped his toughest competition in his prime, Manfredy stopped, Corrales stopped and knocked down for the first time in any of his bouts, he hit the deck 5 times but you can just kiss my ass if you don't agree or accept this because this is my rating, not yours.

For all I care you can put him as a 2, 1 or zero and that's your rating, you won't hear nothing from me on it. You guys always have a problem with anyone giving Floyd credit for anything.

I wasnt referring my comment to you, I was backing up what you were saying. That other guy disagreed with your "9" for power. I said Floyd was a great puncher in his prime. I said I didn't think he was a 9 personally but was close to it. Read those comments over again

[Chepppaaa]

Ali

power 6.5
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10

ali was athletic, but compared to roy, who is a 10, ali was a 8,5-9. i mean 10 is the highest, muhammad ali aint as athletic as jones jr, so no 10

speed 10, hell no, maybe 9-9,5, but ali wasnt no prime medlrick taylor or prime jones in speed.

condition....hell no...look at foremon fight how exhausted he was...

[Chepppaaa]

for me the best ever is Floyd jr, in his prime

power 9
speed 10
ring IQ 10
reflexes 10
chin 10
condition 10
footwork 10
athleticsm 10
_____________
in total 79 out of 80.
https://youtu.be/QGcwFgvGBrU

speedwise very fast at his prime, but no 10, 10 is the fastest, like prime roy, floyd was a 9,5. look at the judah mayweather fight, even judah was faster than floyd and judah aint faster than prime roy

power, like an 8 and the rest is pretty acurate.