Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

watsupdoc87
Super Welterweight
Posts: 2841
Joined: 25 Oct 2014, 14:16

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by watsupdoc87 »

Tarkus wrote:
Tarkus wrote:This is a great fight. Smiths luck is about to run out.
Or not. :OhYes:
I fukin thought he had it there. Great :bag:
crusader
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 16875
Joined: 19 Jan 2009, 20:14

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by crusader »

Smith started strong, but then the gap in skill showed and he did well to last the distance. Barrera is one of those guys who gets hurt but doesn't stay hurt long.
Tarkus
Cruiserweight
Posts: 2859
Joined: 04 Jul 2010, 08:50

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Tarkus »

Thats why you cant rely on punching power alone, no matter how hard you hit.

Barrera vs Gvozdyk would be a feast. Make it happen.
Badhusker
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4902
Joined: 19 Jun 2010, 23:57

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Badhusker »

Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
punchoutsb
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5842
Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by punchoutsb »

I wouldn't be at all surprised to hear something was wrong with Joe coming into the fight. He did not fight like usual at all, and there seemed to be more to it than Barrera's ability.
Blodhemn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2848
Joined: 04 Jun 2006, 20:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Blodhemn »

Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Why's that? Son of Judges didn't look especially good against Barrera, was hit routinely with the jab which was on more display against Kovalev.
Tanzio
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 12264
Joined: 04 Feb 2012, 09:17

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Tanzio »

Blodhemn wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Why's that? Son of Judges didn't look especially good against Barrera, was hit routinely with the jab which was on more display against Kovalev.
Let's see how Krushedner does v Barrera.
Badhusker
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4902
Joined: 19 Jun 2010, 23:57

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Badhusker »

Blodhemn wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Why's that? Son of Judges didn't look especially good against Barrera, was hit routinely with the jab which was on more display against Kovalev.
.

I just don't think most people realize how skilled Ward is, and don't think he is given credit because people hate him. If it was Kovalev that won their two fights, most people would rank him #1pfp without question. Barerra was a very accomplished amateur, and is quite skilled as far as I can see. I thought considering the competition, Ward did very well vs Barerra. I think Barerra would give Kovalev all he could handle, and then some. I think Kovalev is a much better boxer than Smith, but with less power.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Jip »

Am i the only one who thought barrera won against ward?
Mexi-Box
Welterweight
Posts: 3963
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 16:19

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Mexi-Box »

Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Jip »

Mexi-Box wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Barrera won the fight. Nobody outclassed nobody. It was a okay fight where both landed a lot on the guard or punched in the air. Classic home descision. Barrera landed the clearer punches, snapped ward head a couple of times back. Barrera ud win, kovalev ud win, kovalev II dq win. Ward lost these 3 fights. All gifts. He wont never face bertebiev or gvozdyk. Those guys dont gass after 6 rds and have equal or more punching power than kovalev..
Badhusker
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4902
Joined: 19 Jun 2010, 23:57

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Badhusker »

Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Barrera won the fight. Nobody outclassed nobody. It was a okay fight where both landed a lot on the guard or punched in the air. Classic home descision. Barrera landed the clearer punches, snapped ward head a couple of times back. Barrera ud win, kovalev ud win, kovalev II dq win. Ward lost these 3 fights. All gifts. He wont never face bertebiev or gvozdyk. Those guys dont gass after 6 rds and have equal or more punching power than kovalev..
In your expert opinion, has Ward ever won a legitimate boxing match, or did he win because of a hometown advantage or by cheating? :roll:
armageto
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5260
Joined: 04 Nov 2004, 20:15

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by armageto »

Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Barrera won the fight. Nobody outclassed nobody. It was a okay fight where both landed a lot on the guard or punched in the air. Classic home descision. Barrera landed the clearer punches, snapped ward head a couple of times back. Barrera ud win, kovalev ud win, kovalev II dq win. Ward lost these 3 fights. All gifts. He wont never face bertebiev or gvozdyk. Those guys dont gass after 6 rds and have equal or more punching power than kovalev..
Well, time to shuffle up my blocked list again........

I could see not liking a fighter, but this is just plain stupidity. Ward CLEARLY won the Barrera fight. Kovalev won both fights, but then you claim he gassed after 6 rounds, so basically finding an excuse as to why he lost......
Blodhemn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2848
Joined: 04 Jun 2006, 20:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Blodhemn »

Badhusker wrote:I just don't think most people realize how skilled Ward is, and don't think he is given credit because people hate him. If it was Kovalev that won their two fights, most people would rank him #1pfp without question. Barerra was a very accomplished amateur, and is quite skilled as far as I can see. I thought considering the competition, Ward did very well vs Barerra. I think Barerra would give Kovalev all he could handle, and then some. I think Kovalev is a much better boxer than Smith, but with less power.
Ward's skill comes from in close, and judging by history, not many fighters of that mold get a lot of credit, since it's ugly boxing. Barrera is good, but I wouldn't put him much above Chilemba really. Both are *solid* but lack just enough to be champs. Kovalev did *win* the first fight, but didn't get official credit, which pretty much derailed his career. Don't have much sympathy for Ward.
Tanzio wrote:Let's see how Krushedner does v Barrera.
Probably pretty well since it'd be a fight at a more comfortable range, unless Kovalev is dead at the weight, which is a possibility.
Tanzio
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 12264
Joined: 04 Feb 2012, 09:17

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Tanzio »

Blodhemn wrote:
Badhusker wrote:I just don't think most people realize how skilled Ward is, and don't think he is given credit because people hate him. If it was Kovalev that won their two fights, most people would rank him #1pfp without question. Barerra was a very accomplished amateur, and is quite skilled as far as I can see. I thought considering the competition, Ward did very well vs Barerra. I think Barerra would give Kovalev all he could handle, and then some. I think Kovalev is a much better boxer than Smith, but with less power.
Ward's skill comes from in close, and judging by history, not many fighters of that mold get a lot of credit, since it's ugly boxing. Barrera is good, but I wouldn't put him much above Chilemba really. Both are *solid* but lack just enough to be champs. Kovalev did *win* the first fight, but didn't get official credit, which pretty much derailed his career. Don't have much sympathy for Ward.
Tanzio wrote:Let's see how Krushedner does v Barrera.
Probably pretty well since it'd be a fight at a more comfortable range, unless Kovalev is dead at the weight, which is a possibility.
That wasn't a question. I would like to see that fight. It would be a great test for both.

SOGgy beat them both, Krushedner twice.
Blodhemn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2848
Joined: 04 Jun 2006, 20:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Blodhemn »

Tanzio wrote:
Blodhemn wrote:
Badhusker wrote:I just don't think most people realize how skilled Ward is, and don't think he is given credit because people hate him. If it was Kovalev that won their two fights, most people would rank him #1pfp without question. Barerra was a very accomplished amateur, and is quite skilled as far as I can see. I thought considering the competition, Ward did very well vs Barerra. I think Barerra would give Kovalev all he could handle, and then some. I think Kovalev is a much better boxer than Smith, but with less power.
Ward's skill comes from in close, and judging by history, not many fighters of that mold get a lot of credit, since it's ugly boxing. Barrera is good, but I wouldn't put him much above Chilemba really. Both are *solid* but lack just enough to be champs. Kovalev did *win* the first fight, but didn't get official credit, which pretty much derailed his career. Don't have much sympathy for Ward.
Tanzio wrote:Let's see how Krushedner does v Barrera.
Probably pretty well since it'd be a fight at a more comfortable range, unless Kovalev is dead at the weight, which is a possibility.
That wasn't a question. I would like to see that fight. It would be a great test for both.

SOGgy beat them both, Krushedner twice.
Not really.
Tanzio
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 12264
Joined: 04 Feb 2012, 09:17

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Tanzio »

Blodhemn wrote:
Tanzio wrote:
Blodhemn wrote: Ward's skill comes from in close, and judging by history, not many fighters of that mold get a lot of credit, since it's ugly boxing. Barrera is good, but I wouldn't put him much above Chilemba really. Both are *solid* but lack just enough to be champs. Kovalev did *win* the first fight, but didn't get official credit, which pretty much derailed his career. Don't have much sympathy for Ward.


Probably pretty well since it'd be a fight at a more comfortable range, unless Kovalev is dead at the weight, which is a possibility.
That wasn't a question. I would like to see that fight. It would be a great test for both.

SOGgy beat them both, Krushedner twice.
Not really.
It is official, SOGgy is the only boxer to defeat each of them. It only makes sense that they fight each other.
Blodhemn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2848
Joined: 04 Jun 2006, 20:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Blodhemn »

Tanzio wrote: It is official, SOGgy is the only boxer to defeat each of them. It only makes sense that they fight each other.
If you need loopy logic to justify a fight then it probably isn't the best one to be made. Since they're both with Duva and haven't fought yet, I doubt it happens, but maybe you'll get your wish for this highly sought after fight.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Jip »

armageto wrote:
Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote: Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Barrera won the fight. Nobody outclassed nobody. It was a okay fight where both landed a lot on the guard or punched in the air. Classic home descision. Barrera landed the clearer punches, snapped ward head a couple of times back. Barrera ud win, kovalev ud win, kovalev II dq win. Ward lost these 3 fights. All gifts. He wont never face bertebiev or gvozdyk. Those guys dont gass after 6 rds and have equal or more punching power than kovalev..
Well, time to shuffle up my blocked list again........

I could see not liking a fighter, but this is just plain stupidity. Ward CLEARLY won the Barrera fight. Kovalev won both fights, but then you claim he gassed after 6 rounds, so basically finding an excuse as to why he lost......
Kovalev won, but didnt look great doing it. Him gassing after 6 was poor. Yet it was enough to win the first fight. Well the seconde was a dq win for him.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Jip »

Badhusker wrote:
Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote: Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.
Barrera won the fight. Nobody outclassed nobody. It was a okay fight where both landed a lot on the guard or punched in the air. Classic home descision. Barrera landed the clearer punches, snapped ward head a couple of times back. Barrera ud win, kovalev ud win, kovalev II dq win. Ward lost these 3 fights. All gifts. He wont never face bertebiev or gvozdyk. Those guys dont gass after 6 rds and have equal or more punching power than kovalev..
In your expert opinion, has Ward ever won a legitimate boxing match, or did he win because of a hometown advantage or by cheating? :roll:
He obviously is an outstanding boxers and 95 % of his fights.
victor-romeo
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1634
Joined: 18 Sep 2004, 22:29

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by victor-romeo »

Joe Smith got lucky, they threw him in the deep end of the pool and he got a boxing lesson, without getting his brains scrambled too bad. Hopefully he was taking notes. I am sure he will be better fighter after this experience.
caldo2025
Super Welterweight
Posts: 4417
Joined: 16 Dec 2014, 07:37

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by caldo2025 »

Just like i figured...Smith is a nice story with some power but he's a one trick pony. If he doesn't land a bomb, most legitimate light heavies will pick him apart like SB did. I would still like to see Smith fight again. Why they decided to put him in there with SB at this point is silly IMO. Let the kid be a full time boxer for a year first.
Badhusker
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4902
Joined: 19 Jun 2010, 23:57

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Badhusker »

Mexi-Box wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.



I had to look back on the fight to make sure I wasn't mistaken. Barerra was competitive, but was beaten with no questions.
The Scoring: 117-109, 117-109, 119-107. Barrera went down once in Round 3. Barerra has had two fights since then, and the Ward fight was in March of 2016. It was also Ward's first fight at 175.

Maybe you should try some Kool-Aid.
Mexi-Box
Welterweight
Posts: 3963
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 16:19

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Mexi-Box »

Badhusker wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote:
Badhusker wrote:Smith had a puncher's chance, but was shut out easily after round one. Totally out classed. Commentators were annoying, but I agree it shows just how good Ward is, the way he handled Barrera.
Ward didn't outclass Barrera, though. You're drinking the HBO Kool-Aid. A lot of people thought Ward didn't look great. Also, Barrera went into the Ward fight with no experience at the top level. Dude was still very much in the prospect stage of his career.



I had to look back on the fight to make sure I wasn't mistaken. Barerra was competitive, but was beaten with no questions.
The Scoring: 117-109, 117-109, 119-107. Barrera went down once in Round 3. Barerra has had two fights since then, and the Ward fight was in March of 2016. It was also Ward's first fight at 175.

Maybe you should try some Kool-Aid.
Thing is, I'm not at all saying Barrera won. My point still stands, though. It was competitive throughout. It wasn't close, but people cited that fight as Ward declining. I also give zero fcks what the judges scorecards are for any fight. The fact that you cite them tells me a lot about you.
Blodhemn
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2848
Joined: 04 Jun 2006, 20:30

Re: Joe Smith vs Sullivan Barrera

Post by Blodhemn »

Yeah, that fight against Barrera is what sealed the deal for me picking against SOJ vs Kovalev. Got hit by too many jabs, though still won. It's revisionist history to say SOJ looked great there, but that's Kellerman's way of daydreaming over his favorites while others are fighting.
Post Reply