HomicideHenry wrote: ↑27 Aug 2021, 16:02
Mandatories do not equate to being the best possible challengers.
cs: If that's true you can only blame the governing bodies. They can make Joshua fight any heavyweight in the world. I think it's only Sulaiman who is answerable to a third party in terms of who he can nominate and when the mandatory gets called.
There's not a single person that Anthony Joshua has fought other than Vladimir Klitschko that is in the same category as Wilder or Fury.
cs: That's hardly Joshua's fault. He can't force them to fight him, and if his three belts aren't incentive enough, what is he supposed to do? He has fought everyone who matters, who has agreed to face him. I don't think it will be long before at least one of Joyce, Hrgovic, Yoka will share the ring with him and still Wilder's best win will be a faded Luis Ortiz.
To be fair though, Wilder never fought anyone who was in the same category as Joshua prior to his fight with Fury. To be fair though, with the exception of Vladimir Klitschko, Fury never fought anyone in the category of Joshua.
cs: Prior to getting annihilated by Fury, Wilder has only beaten Ortiz and arguably Stiverne, who are on a similar level to Povetkin, Parker, Whyte, Pulev, Ruiz, did I miss anyone? Take away Klitschko and Wilder (extremely impressive, don't get me wrong) then Fury's best wins are probably Chisora, Hammer and Cunningham.
Someone may try to say Usyk is in that same category strictly because he was the undisputed cruiserweight champion, and has amazing skills--- but I think anyone who is really objective will point out that he's not as effective as a heavyweight as he was as a cruiserweight.
cs: He hasn't shown much so far at heavyweight but many would regard him as number four ahead of Dillian Whyte. Apart from each other, how many times have Wilder or Fury fought an opponent who is inside the top 10? Klitschko, Ortiz and Stiverne I make it. That's a combined total of three unless I've forgotten anyone.
I don't know of anyone who was really all that impressed with that fight with the over the hill Dereck Chisora, unless they are easily impressed.
cs: I guess it confirms he can stay afloat among the heavyweights, not that he can necessarily impact the pinnacle of the division.
If I was a world class heavyweight champion I would have no qualms facing mandatories either especially when you know they are quite a few rungs beneath you in terms of skills or quality.
cs: That's what separates a real champion from a fake. Mandatories should be the best possible opponents but sometimes politics gets in the way. I don't think you can complain too loudly about Whyte, Pulev, Usyk, and probably Hrgovic though, can you?
If anyone was seemingly unwilling to fight the best it has to be Wilder, because the only reason why he took on Fury in the first place was because he honestly believed him to be done as a heavyweight--- so he took far less money, in the hopes of getting the lineal championship, rather than the big money fight with Joshua to unify the titles.
cs: Congratulations Hank. Finally a cousin across the pond who recognizes that taking on Fury for the first time wasn't intended to be a 50/50 showdown between rival champions. Fury was seen as a busted flush, another easy kill only this one with a name who would add stardust to Deontay's pitiful resumé. It was never meant to be that difficult.
Of course the two fights with Fury showed everybody that Wilder clearly is the third best in the world, and when Joshua lost Andy Ruiz it showed the world that Tyson Fury had to be the best in the world because it is very difficult to imagine Fury losing to Snickers. Yes, Joshua avenged his loss but it was one of the most lackluster wins I have ever seen.
cs: Wilder is clearly no better than third in the world but I don't believe that even the pre-beatdown Wilder beats Joyce or Hrgovic and for me the jury is out on Whyte, Usyk, Ruiz, Parker and previously Povetkin or Pulev of a couple of years ago. As for being very difficult to imagine Fury losing to Ruiz, I agree. Most people felt the same way about Joshua. To me it's a classic styles make fights. Fury would beat Ruiz quite easily. Joshua will always struggle with Ruiz, and for me Joshua knocks out Fury. Of course my face may not always remain devoid of egg